How To Sell Your Old Pokémon Cards For Cash

Share the wealth!

Over the past year, Pokémon cards have seen a surge of interest that is shocking hardcore fans and economists alike. In the past month alone, there have been dozens of instances of cards selling for over $100,000 with one pristine, first-print Charizard card selling for a staggering $420,000.

With money like that flying around, it’s no surprise that people are taking a closer look at their old cards and wondering if they could be sitting on a gold mine. So, how can you tell if your cards are worth anything? And how do you go about selling them if they are?

Keep reading to find out!

How to find the price of your Pokémon cards

When it comes to collectibles—and especially collectible cards—prices are highly variable. If you look on eBay right now, you’ll see some Pokémon cards selling for $1 and others selling for tens of thousands of dollars. I even managed to find a rare card autographed by Ken Sugimori himself selling for $800,000!

So, there’s clearly a massive range of prices when it comes to Pokémon cards. But what dictates these prices? There are three main factors:

  • Grade
  • Rarity
  • Recognizability

Let’s unpack these three factors!

Pokémon card grade

When you go to buy something, you’d probably be willing to pay more if it was in good condition. That mentality is exactly what makes grading such an influential factor in determining the price of collectibles like Pokémon cards.

For those that aren’t familiar with the term, grading is simply a system for numerically or symbolically describing the condition of a card. There are a few popular grading systems used by Pokémon card collectors and sellers, including:

  • The PSA Grading Scale
  • The CSG Grading Scale
  • The Beckett Grading Scale

While these scales differ slightly in their terminology, they all do essentially the same thing. Cards are placed on a spectrum ranging from mint condition to poor according to certain criteria.

The most important thing to understand is that the grade of a card will have a direct impact on its value. A card with a higher grade will almost always be worth more than a lower-grade version of the same card.

Pokémon card rarity

Of course, the grade isn’t the only thing that can affect the price of your Pokémon cards—their rarity is also an important factor. Generally speaking, rarer cards tend to sell for higher prices than common ones.

So, how do you know if a card is rare? There’s one incredibly reliable method.

The Pokémon card creators were nice enough to provide a handy system of symbols for getting a basic understanding of a card’s rarity. On the bottom left-hand corner of the card, you’ll see one of four symbols:

  • Circle: Denotes a common card.
  • Diamond: Denotes an uncommon card.
  • Star: Denotes a rare card.
  • Promo Star: Denotes an extremely rare promotional card.

As you move up the rarity scale, card prices will (usually) increase. But don’t worry too much if your card isn’t particularly rare according to this basic scale—collectors tend to pay more attention to things like autographs and first-pressings (first editions) than they do rarity when it comes to Pokémon cards.

Pokémon card popularity

The final factor that can have a big impact on the price of your cards is their popularity. This quality refers to how ubiquitous the card is and what kind of audience it has. For example, a very popular card that everyone recognizes—like Charizard or Pikachu—might be worth more than a more obscure card that has less of an audience.

There isn’t a hard and fast set of rules behind this factor like there is with both of the previous factors. However, it’s still an important point to understand.

So, if you’re looking to sell your old Pokémon cards for cash, keep these three factors in mind: check the grade of your cards, consider their rarity, and think about their recognizability.

How to sell your Pokémon cards for cash

Now that you know a little bit about the factors that influence card prices, you’re probably wondering: how do I sell my Pokémon cards for cash? Don’t worry—we’re here to help!

Step 1: Screen Your Collections

The first step to selling your old Pokémon cards is to sort through what you have and screen out the cards that aren’t worth very much (i.e., most of them). You can do this by going through each of your collections individually and keeping track of any card grades, rarities, or other factors that might affect their value.

Cards that are badly torn or worn can usually be thrown away, unless you believe they’re extremely rare. At this stage, it’s best to take a cautious approach—when in doubt, keep it!

Common cards—even pristine ones—typically only sell for a few dollars (at most). So, it’s up to you to decide whether it’s worth the effort. 

Tip: If you have a lot of pristine common cards, it’s often easier to sell them as a package!

Step 2: Identify Your Best Cards

Now that you’ve sorted through your collections, it’s time to take a closer look at the cards that might still be worth something.

Ideally, these are cards that are both high-quality and rare. While they might not sell for as much as you were hoping, they’re probably still worth more than most of the other ones in your collection. In this case, it’s best to sell them individually—try reaching out to private buyers on websites like Craigslist or eBay.

Step 3: Do Your Research

Before you try selling your Pokémon cards on an individual basis, it’s important to do your research first! For example, if you’re planning on selling them via eBay, make sure you check how much comparable versions of each card have sold for in the past.

To get started, look up a few different card guides online to get an idea of what your cards should be worth. From there, search on eBay or other similar sites to see how much they actually sell for.

Alternatively, you can post your cards to forums, such as:

  • Pokémon Card Collections
  • Pokémon Community

While different forums have different rules, most will be happy to take a look at your collection to answer your questions about rarity and condition. With this information in hand, you’ll be able to more accurately price your own cards—and hopefully make a nice profit!

Step 4: Get High-Value Cards Graded

Once you’ve received estimates on how much your best cards are worth, it’s time to get them professionally graded. This will ensure that they sell for the highest possible price.

You can find a number of reputable grading services online, such as PSA or Beckett Grading Services. When you send in your cards, make sure you include a note describing what they are and their condition—and don’t forget to attach any pictures of the back or front!

Step 5: List Your Pokemon Cards & Take Profit

Once you’ve screened your collections, it’s time for the best part: selling your cards!

To do this, you have to find online buyers who will be willing to pay you for them. There are a variety of places where you can list your cards and get offers from potential buyers.

After you’ve found some interested buyers, it’s time to close the sale and take your profit!

Where to sell Pokemon cards for cash

Here’s a list of great places to check out where you can potentially sell your Pokemon cards for cash:

  • Cardmarket: A great, purpose-built trading card marketplace with an active community.
  • eBay: Good for selling cards of all different values, but look out for scammers if you’re selling high-value cards.
  • Craigslist: Good for selling low-value cards in high volume if you’re looking to get rid of them as quickly as possible.
  • Online Auction Houses: If you’re selling extremely rare cards, it’s recommended that you use a professional auction house (e.g., Barneby’s) to minimize risk.

Whichever route you choose, it’s important to keep in mind that investing in Pokémon cards can be extremely lucrative. With some research and patience, you should be able to get top dollar for your cards—and have a blast doing it!

In conclusion

If you’re looking to sell your old Pokémon cards for cash, follow these simple steps! Sorting through your collection, identifying the best cards, and doing your research are all essential parts of the process.

And don’t forget: getting your cards graded can help maximize their value. With a little effort, you should be able to get top dollar for your Pokémon card collections! Good luck!